Social Media Marketing Agency VS In-House Team: What’s Best For Your Melbourne Business

Details

Building a dynamic and powerful media presence is not just an option for Melbourne businesses. If you are trying to boost brand awareness, engagement, generate qualified leads, and drive higher sales, social media has become one of the most significant and popular digital marketing platforms. Business owners nowadays have one common doubt: whether they should hire an in-house team or partner with a social media marketing agency!

Both can help you grow your business. But when it comes to cost, scalability, expertise, and long-term business ROI (Return on Investment), you can see the difference. Hiring a social media marketer or an in-house team can give you internal resources. On the other hand, partnering with an agency gives you direct access to a team of industry experts without even paying them for full-time employment.

In this article, I am going to compare the major financial and operational factors that Melbourne businesses must consider when choosing the best option for achieving their desired marketing goals.

social media marketing agency vs in-house comparison for melbourne businesses

Which Delivers Higher ROI?

1. High Victorian Overhead & Payroll Costs

One of the significant differences in hiring an employee or in-house team and partnering with a Social Media Marketing Agency Melbourne is the costing. Hiring a full-time employee can lead to regular business expenses for extra employment costs.

A professional Social Media Manager in Melbourne usually gets up to AUD $80,000 – $100,000 yearly as an average salary. The total employment cost can reach approximately AUD $115,000 a year after adding additional employee expenses like WorkCover Victoria insurance, recruitment training, 12% superannuation, paid leave, and office equipment.

Some Melbourne agencies generally charge approximately AUD $800 to $5,000 monthly, based on the type of services and support level. These social media marketing service packages might include content creation, campaign management, strategy building, paid advertising, and regular performance reporting.

Small businesses with a tight budget can hire Impact Media Oz to get affordable service packages starting from AUD $300 monthly. They can give your business easy access to professional services at an affordable pricing.

2. Tool Costs

An excellent social media marketing strategy depends on professional and advanced software for post scheduling, content creation, performance analysis, and campaign management. Having paid access to these tools can increase the overall business operating cost.

An in-house team or employee might need a paid or premium subscription plan for tools like

Adobe Creative Cloud
Canva Pro
ChatGPT paid version
Buffer
HootSuite
Sprout Social
Scheduling tools
Video editing tools
Analytics platforms

Some agencies already took subscriptions to premium marketing tools and add access to their service. Businesses get free access to paid enterprise-level software without even purchasing it or personal subscriptions. This reduces both the administrative tasks and overall costing.

So, choosing a social media marketing agency can be a wise investment.

3. Skill Set

Successfully managing social media accounts needs industry expertise across different backgrounds, from creating content to analytics and advertising. You can’t expect one person to have multiple skills or mastery over various disciplines can be unrealistic.

Being an in-house social media marketing manager, you are assigned to different roles such as;

Graphic design
Video editing
Content creation
Paid advertising
Copywriting
Performance reporting
Community management

It is very difficult for an individual to specialise in multiple areas.

A social media marketing agency offers businesses the acces to a team of industry experts such as a social media marketing specialist, graphic designer, video editor, advertising expert, copywriter, and analyst. Each professionals have expertise in their specific areas, and they help you create high-converting campaigns and deliver improved marketing performance.

So, a social media marketing agency is clearly the winner here.

4. Ramp-Up Time

Planning an effective social media marketing strategy needs time, particularly when you are hiring someone. Starting from recruiting to onboarding, this process can delay social media campaigns and slow business growth.

Hiring internally typically involves multiple stages before marketing activities even start. Those cover;

Advertisement for the position
Application review
Conduct interviews
Recruitment completion
Employee notice periods
Employee training and onboarding

Usually, this process takes 5 to 8 weeks for most of the businesses. New hirings might require extra time to understand company goals, products, services, and brand message before even planning social media strategy or delivering higher business results.

A social media marketing agency in Melbourne can start working immediately after onboarding. As agencies have industry-experienced professionals and pre-built workflows, they can make effective strategies quickly, create engaging content, and launch social media marketing campaigns without a longer training period or recruitment process.

5. Best For

You can choose the right one based on your business size, marketing goals, brand voice, and resources. Both options have their unique benefits and are best for different types of businesses or company sizes.

Internal hiring can be the best option for businesses that;

Have a larger in-house marketing team
Require regular on-site content creation
Need consistent collaboration among each department
Generate high volumes of product visuals or video content

A social media marketing agency is best for;

Local, small or mid-sized businesses
E-commerce brands
Startups
Businesses that want measurable ROI
Professional service providers

Rather than depending on an in-house team or an individual employee, businesses directly take services from a professional team or agency to manage predictable marketing

6. Favourable Tax Structure for Agencies

Financial choices also impact whether businesses go with an in-house agency or hire an external marketing agency, beyond marketing performance.

According to the State Revenue Office of Victoria website, businesses located in Victoria are subject to pay 4.85% tax on payroll if their wages are taxable, which is above AUD $1 million. Payroll duties grow with insurance, superannuation, and related employment costs as more employees are hired.

Agency hiring expenses are usually marked as operating expenses, not as payroll costs. This means your business can invest in professional services without paying higher payroll taxes. While each business depends on an accountant for advice on tax matters, outsourcing offers you more flexibility than spending on an external team.

7. Victorian Fair Work & Leave Compliance

Hiring employees comes with many legal and administrative duties and is not limited to paying salaries.

Businesses should follow Australian employment norms and regulations like;

Personal leave: 10 days
Annual leave: 20 days
Public holidays
Performance management
Fair Work Act Compliance
Long-service leave entitlements
Employment termination processes

Managing such duties needs additional HR resources and time, which is difficult, especially for small businesses without a well-organized and professional HR team.

While partnering with an agency, the above-mentioned employer duties remain under the agency itself. Businesses get uninterrupted marketing assistance without thinking much about leave policies, recruitment, Compliance, or employment rules and regulations.

This drastically lowers operations issues and enables business owners to focus more on running their businesses than handling in-house employment problems.

Why Many Melbourne Businesses Choose Impact Media Oz

Choosing a trustworthy marketing agency is extremely important. Most Melbourne businesses partner with Impact Media Oz as it offers complete professional social media marketing services at an affordable price.

Businesses can directly access a team of experience industry professionals who manage strategy, planning, content creation, campaign building, advertising, campaign performance management, and optimization under 1-month service contracts.

Impact Media Oz is popular for delivering;

Customized social media marketing strategy as per business goals.
Creative and engaging content for Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn.
Meta Ads campaign management.
Responsive customer support.
Daily performance tracking and monthly performance reporting.

Impact Media Oz’s affordable social media marketing solutions start from just AUD $300 monthly. This is highly recommended for startups, small or local businesses looking for professional outcomes without investing much in employee recruitment and training.

Final Thoughts,

One-size-fits-all rule is not applied when choosing the best marketing team for your business, whether it’s an in-house team or hiring a professional social media marketing agency. Always choose according to your business size, budget, marketing objectives, and internal resources.

An in-house team is the best fit for large organizations where daily on-site content generation is needed, and there is easy collaboration among different teams. But for Melbourne small or mid-sized businesses, hiring a social media marketing agency offers higher value by minimizing additional employment expenses.

Ready to get started?

Are you ready
Let’s Make Something Amazing Together

Need help? Contact our expart

Tell us about our project

Table of Contents

Which Delivers Higher ROI?